The Gmail box access settings seem to be correct and have been tested from an email client.
When the cron job is manually ran, the following output is displayed.
root@li278-95:~# php /path/to/cli/ats-mail-fetch.php
Akeeba Ticket System -- Fetch email for the Reply By Email feature
Copyright 2011-2013 Nicholas K. Dionysopoulos / AkeebaBackup.com
===============================================================================
Preparing to check for email
You have new mail in /var/mail/root
No tickets are added to ATS.
Environment:
Joomla 2.5.14
ATS Pro 1.2.3
Gmail (POP, Port 995, SSL, TLS whenever possible)