We didn't change the icons just because the decades old Everaldo Crystal Icons set was long in the tooth. We changed it for reasons of usability, consistency, efficiency and responsiveness. As with anything artistic some people will like it, some people won't. I'm sorry you don't like it.
If you are as upset as you come across, feel free to provide us with a vector icon set which fulfills ALL of the following requirements:
- visually fits in Joomla! 3, Joomla! 4 and WordPress at the same time.
- has enough icons to represent all the abstract concepts among our very diverse software, something that the Everaldo Crystal Icons set and the custom Akeeba Backup set designed by Helvecio for us a couple of years ago did not cater for, making us reuse unrelated and confusing icons, leading to an inconsistent design and cognitive burden to the users of our software.
- can be shipped as compact set of icon fonts in at least TTF, EOT and WOFF formats instead of massively huge PNGs for reasons of efficiency and not crashing your sites when installing our software.
- allows us to create subsets if need be for the same reasons.
- comes with its own icon font CSS which can be namespaced to avoid conflicts.
- scales nicely from 16px to 1024px without artefacts since our software is responsive, i.e. can be used in anything from a 4" smartphone to a 45" 8K display.
- works on a variety of color background so we can give color context to our users.
- allows redistribution and use in commercial software without a fee so we don't have to increase our prices.
Let me comment that the IonIcons set we use not only fits all those requirements but also follows the flat, abstract design of iOS, Android, Windows, Joomla 3, Joomla 4 and WordPress itself. That's in stark contrast to the old icon sets. The Everaldo Crystal Icons dated back to the early 00's era of skeuomorphic 3D-cartoon icons (e.g. Windows XP, iOS 4, Android 1). The custom Akeeba Backup icon set -which was tying our hands- was a nod to the 8-bit computer era with blocky, pixelated icons. Both of them made our software look dated and out of touch with the current design trends in the computer industry.
Which brings me to an honest question: how can even use a computer if you have such a strong reaction to flat, abstract icons? Are you using XFce or a retro icon set? How about all of the sites. Even Joomla! 3.8 has done away with gradients and gone almost full flat (bar some icons from the IcoMoon set that nobody wants to rip out until Joomla! 4 is out).
Nicholas K. Dionysopoulos
Lead Developer and Director
🇬🇷Greek: native 🇬🇧English: excellent 🇫🇷French: basic • 🕐 My time zone is Europe / Athens
Please keep in mind my timezone and cultural differences when reading my replies. Thank you!